When Judges Get “It” Wrong

United States Circuit Judge Andrew Hurwitz pondered this notion in his recent essay published by the Arizona Law Review: “When Judges Err: Is Confession Good for the Soul?”

Most judges are keenly aware that the consequences for making mistakes — whether legal, factual, or simply typographical — can have far-reaching implications. And yet, everyone makes the occasional mistake at some point in his or her career. Judge Hurwitz explores in his essay what the natural next step for the judge might be:

“This essay focuses not on commendable explanations of why judges change their minds about the appropriate rule of law after mature reconsideration, but instead on, for want of a better description, how courts handle the judicial ‘goof’ – getting the applicable facts or existing law dead wrong. Interestingly, although many examples can be found of judges explaining why their previous view of the law has evolved, there are relatively few published decisions acknowledging common human error. My thesis is that we all would be better off if judges freely acknowledged and transparently corrected the occasional ‘goof.’ Confession is not only good for the soul, it also buttresses respect for the law and increases the public’s understanding of the human limitations of the judicial system.”

How does a judge account for an error with dignity and grace? Judge Hurwitz provides two good examples of judges who identify and correct their errs; in fact, transparently describing errors in opinions can have positive effects for future decision-making.

To read the essay, please download it here. Article citation is 56 Ariz. L. Rev. 343.

NJC News
Washington DC Supreme Court facade equal justice under the law
Almost all judges believe Supreme Court justices should be subject to an ethics code

It’s safe to say that judges think their brethren and sistren on the U.S. Supreme Court should be bound b...

Remembering Lee Sinclair

Photo courtesy of The Repository Lee Sinclair recalled that as a child he loved to visit the Stark Count...

Remembering Dean Larry Hyde

Judge Laurance M. “Larry” Hyde, the dean who established The National Judicial College on the campu...

Interior of cell block in abandoned State Correctional Institution, or jail., common room with jail cells.
Poll suggests that judges know what life is like in their jails and prisons

Judges who send people to jail or prison usually have at least some idea of the conditions in the facilitie...

Judicial Heroes and Legends: May 2022 - Hon. Constance Baker Motley

When Ketanji Brown Jackson was nominated to become the first Black woman justice of the U.S. Supreme Co...

View All News

Download a PDF of our complete 2022 course catalog