Ask the Model Code: Can I accept gifts?

Dear Model Code:

When someone gives me a gift I often wonder whether I can accept it, and if I do, whether I have to disclose the fact. What are the rules?


Judge Gifted & Tormented

Dear Judge Tormented:

Rule 3.13 begins: “A judge shall not accept any gifts, loans, bequests, benefits, or other things of value if acceptance is prohibited by law or would appear to a reasonable person to undermine the judge’s independence, integrity, or impartiality.”

The text goes on to list a number of situations when gifts to judges need not be reported.These include: items with little intrinsic value; gifts from friends and relatives; and gifts resulting from ordinary social hospitality. You also don’t have to report gifts that are so obviously prejudicial that they disqualify you and you never actually hear the case.

Depending on the circumstances, judges might be able to accept items of value that come from people (or people’s interests) that have come or are likely to come before the judge. But these items must be reported. For obvious reasons, be very careful, and when in doubt don’t accept them.

As mentioned, gifts from family and friends are generally OK, but how close does the person have to be to qualify as a “friend”? And what exactly is meant by “ordinary social hospitality” or “little intrinsic value”?  Bottom line: Always be sensitive to appearances.


The Model Code of Judicial Conduct

NJC News
A Lawless judge on the bench

Click here for the editor’s note* I would hear a few jokes and comments over the years regarding my na...

Sign on granite at the US Department of Me.  ;-)
Prosecutorial Justice

I became the tribal prosecutor for the Shoshone and Arapaho tribes of the Wind River Indian Reservation in ...

Bench takes the bench

I grew up wanting to be a lawyer but not because of my name. When I first ran for office, my name was re...

The advantages of following the Law

My last name came from my first marriage and it has always been a benefit during my legal career. I am also...

Judge squared

Click here for the editor’s note* Despite my last name, I never set out to be a judge, even after I be...

View All News

Download a PDF of our complete 2020 course catalog